The hallway closet in my first apartment had exactly one shelf and a bar for coats, and every winter I'd stand there trying to fit snow boots, a toolbox, board games, and whatever my mother had decided I needed that I never asked for. It wasn't until I put a plain storage cabinet against the wall near the door that the whole entry stopped looking like a problem I was ignoring. Closed doors, one flat surface on top for keys and mail, and suddenly the mess had an address.
If you're starting with nothing, go for a cabinet with doors before you get tempted by open shelving or anything with a long row of drawers. Doors hide the chaos, which matters more than people admit, because not everything you own is folded and color coded, and a closed door doesn't ask you to pretend otherwise. Solid wood is lovely and it'll outlast you, but it's heavy to move and it costs like it. For everyday living, a painted MDF or a laminate cabinet holds up fine, wipes clean, and doesn't flinch when a kid leans a bike against it. Drawers are worth adding once you know what you're storing, since they're better for anything you dig through often, linens, cords, the junk drawer that migrated out of the kitchen, while shelves behind a door suit things you grab in one piece, like serving platters or board games in their boxes. This kind of cabinet earns its spot in an entryway, a home office, a kid's room, a laundry area, or that dead stretch of wall every living room has that's too awkward for a sofa and too obvious to ignore. It's especially good in a rental, where you can't build in storage and don't want to drill fifteen holes trying. Humid climates and summer are no trouble for wood veneer or laminate, but raw or unsealed wood in a bathroom or a mudroom with real weather coming through the door will warp and swell faster than you'd expect, so skip that pairing entirely.
Where it clashes is in a room that's already busy with pattern or with other large case pieces. Two tall cabinets facing each other in a small room just makes a hallway feel like a corridor in an office building, and a heavily grained wood cabinet next to a sleek glass front sideboard looks like two different arguments happening at once. Pick one material language per room and let the cabinet be the quiet one.
The mistake is buying it for the look of the front and ignoring the depth. A cabinet that's too shallow for what you actually own just becomes another thing you have to work around, and you'll know within a week.