The moment I notice a fabric chair is worth it is halfway through a long dinner, when everyone's still sitting there talking and nobody's shifting around trying to get comfortable on a hard seat. That's the whole pitch. Wood and leather chairs look great for the first twenty minutes. Fabric is what gets you through dessert.
The gap between a good one and a bad one shows up fast, and it shows up in places you wouldn't think to check first. Cheap ones have fabric stretched over foam that's already started going flat in the showroom, stapled on in a way that puckers at the corners within a year. Good ones have the fabric pulled tight and tucked properly, no visible staples, no puckering, and the frame underneath is solid wood, not three thin strips glued together and hoping. Push down on the seat in the store. If you feel the frame flex or hear a creak, that's the chair telling you everything about year two. The joints matter more than people expect from something that just holds a seat cushion, because a dining chair gets pulled out, sat in, leaned back on, and bumped into the table edge probably four times a day. Weak joints loosen. Good ones are doweled or mortise and tenon, not just glued end grain. As for the fabric itself, a performance weave or a tight weave cotton blend shrugs off spills far better than a loose linen look, which is gorgeous and will hold a red wine stain forever. Ask before you buy whether it's actually treated for stains, because "wipeable" printed on a tag means almost nothing.
Where fabric chairs go wrong is anywhere wet or anywhere small children eat unsupervised. A breakfast nook with a toddler flinging yogurt is a leather or vinyl situation, full stop, and I say that as someone who has scrubbed a cream fabric seat pad with a toothbrush at eleven at night. They're also not the move for an outdoor dining set or a sunroom that gets direct light all day, since fabric fades and weakens in strong sun faster than you'd expect. Where they do real work is around a regular dining table in a room people actually live in, mixed in with a wood table top, maybe two fabric chairs at the ends and simpler chairs along the sides so the whole set doesn't feel matchy. A patterned seat against a plain table calms a busy room down instead of adding to it.
I'd put a low pendant light right over the table, close enough that the glow catches the fabric texture at dinner instead of washing it out from above.
Aisha's pickFabric Head Chairs That Look Better in Real Life
Aisha's pickLuxury Fabric Dining Chairs That Get the Family Around the Table
Aisha's pickFabric Mesh Office Chairs That Won’t Date in a Year
Aisha's pickModern Fabric Dining Chairs Comfy Enough for a Movie Night
Aisha's pickFabric Office Chairs for Making a House Feel Like Yours
Aisha's pickModern Fabric Upholstered Dining Chairs at Every Price Point
Aisha's pickFabric Reading Chairs From Stores Big and Small
Aisha's pickModern Upholstered Dining Chairs That Get the Family Around the Table
Aisha's pickNo Fuss Fabric Reception ChairsAlso worth a lookFabric Dining ChairsFabric dining chairs have a reputation for being the thing that looks great in a catalog and then…See the collections →
Aisha's pickModern Velvet Dining Chairs That Do the Job Right
Aisha's pickDecent Fabric Recliners Without the Hassle
Aisha's pickSets of 2 Fabric Dining Chairs for Long Dinners With Friends
Aisha's pickFabric Recliner Chairs That Are Easy to Keep Clean
Aisha's pickSets of 2 Modern Fabric Dining Chairs With Real Back Support
Aisha's pickFabric Rocking Chairs With a Bit More About Them
Aisha's pickOur Shortlist of Sets of 2 Upholstered Dining Chairs
Aisha's pickVelvet Reading Chairs for Making a House Feel Like Yours
Aisha's pickSets of 2 Upholstered Fabric Dining Chairs That Are Easy to Keep CleanAlso worth a lookErgonomic ChairsThe thing nobody mentions is that an ergonomic chair looks ridiculous for the first two weeks.See the collections →
Aisha's pickBlack Upholstered Dining Chairs That Get the Family Around the Table
Aisha's pickSets of 4 Fabric Dining Chairs That Make a Room Feel Finished
Aisha's pickCurved Back Upholstered Dining Chairs You’ll Keep for Years
Aisha's pickUpholstered Dining Chairs That Fit Through a Narrow Door
Aisha's pickFabric Dining Chairs That Get the Family Around the Table
Aisha's pickUpholstered Dining Chairs with Metal Legs That Are Easy to Keep Clean
Aisha's pickFabric Dining Chairs with Metal Legs That Are Easy to Keep Clean
Aisha's pickVelvet Dining Chairs That Look Good From Every Angle
Aisha's pickFabric Armchairs Picked by People Who Care Too MuchAlso worth a lookSeatsStanding in a showroom trying to decide on seats, the first thing I'd tell you is to sit in it for longer than feels normal.See the collections →
Aisha's pickFabric Upholstered Dining Chairs for Long Dinners With Friends
Aisha's pickFabric Computer Chairs for a Home Office That Works
Aisha's pickHigh Back Upholstered Dining Chairs We’d Happily Nap On
