Our Long Running Wall Mounted Bathroom Cabinet Argument

There is one person on this team who cannot walk past a bathroom cabinet, in a shop, in a rental, in someone else’s house, without opening it to check the shelf spacing. We have watched this happen at a dinner party. We have watched it happen in a hotel in Lisbon. It is not a disagreement so much as a bit at this point, the rest of us waiting for the exact moment the fingers go to the little recessed catch, and someone always says “here we go” under their breath like it’s a magic trick we’ve all seen forty times but still can’t quite look away from.

The actual cabinet in question, the one that lives in the flat share bathroom, is white, unremarkable, has been open and shut probably four times a day for two and a half years, and has never once jammed, which the shelf checker considers a personal vindication every single time it’s brought up.

What nobody argues about is the finish, because the finish is the whole ballgame with these things. Get a matte one and within a month it’s got faint grey fingerprints permanently ghosted around the handle, toothpaste flecks that laugh at a wet cloth. Get gloss and it shows every splash mark within about four seconds of the shower running, but at least those wipe off, actually off, not just smeared thinner.

We went gloss after the matte experiment, and the matte one still lives in a cupboard somewhere as a kind of cautionary object nobody can bring themselves to throw out.

Steam is the real test, not looks.

You Might Also Like

The Day We Finally Replaced the Taper Candle Holder

What We’d Tell a Friend Buying a Round Rug

Living With a Round Dining Table: The Honest Version

A Leather Footstool Six Months In

A cheap mirror front will fog and then dry with these faint streaky tide marks that build up over a year until you’re basically getting dressed by feel. Ours hasn’t done that, which we noticed mostly by absence, nobody mentions the mirror that’s fine, you only ever hear about the ones that aren’t.

The hinge situation gets exactly one sentence here and then we’re done with it: buy one with a soft close or you will hear that door slam at 7am for the rest of your natural life and start resenting a piece of furniture, which is a genuinely strange emotional place to end up in.

Storage inside is where the real personalities come out. One shelf stays completely empty on principle, like it’s being saved for guests who never arrive. The bottom shelf is where everything unlabeled and slightly worrying migrates to die. Nobody claims ownership of the bottom shelf. Everybody uses it.

We’ve never replaced this cabinet and don’t plan to, mostly because it does the one job asked of it without drama, and because retiring it would mean retiring the bit, and the bit is doing more work in this office than the cabinet itself at this point. Some things earn their keep by being useful. This one’s earned it by being the excuse for a joke that’s somehow survived two flat moves and shows no sign of getting old.