There is a chair that lived in a rented flat with terrible light and got compared, unfavorably, for three years to a chair that lived in someone’s actual house with a garden, and that comparison basically wrote this whole argument for us before we’d even sat down to have it. The flat chair was a cognac leather thing from a brand that no longer exists, bought because it looked like the sort of chair a person with their life together would own. It cracked at the seat edge within a year. The house chair, older, uglier, a sort of oxblood that had gone patchy in a way that photographed badly and felt incredible under a hand, is still going eight years later and has survived two dogs and a divorce, not ours, a friend’s, but the chair was there for it. One half of the team thinks this proves you should always buy the ugly one. The other half thinks it proves nothing except that the cognac chair was cheap and we knew it was cheap and bought it anyway because it matched a mood board.
Shopping for these is where it actually falls apart, because a leather dining chair in a shop, under shop lighting, with nothing around it, tells you almost nothing true.
It looks a certain width. It is never that width once it’s home and you’re trying to get six of them around a table that seemed generous in the shop and suddenly feels like a negotiation. Arms are the first casualty. A chair with arms that felt fine as a single display piece will not push under most tables, and you find this out the first time you try to tuck it in and it stops four inches short, permanently, forever, at every dinner from now on.
Doorways get skipped constantly and it is genuinely embarrassing how often.
You Might Also Like
Leather dining chairs do not fold, do not squash, do not forgive a narrow hallway or a tight stairwell turn the way a flat pack anything does. One of us has stood in a stairwell at nine in the evening with a chair wedged sideways, working out whether it’s the chair or the building that has to give, and it was the chair, it always ends up being the chair, and it went back the next week with a faint scuff nobody wants to talk about.
The daily reality once they’re actually in is better than any of this makes it sound. Leather softens where forearms rest, darkens slightly where hands land reaching for a glass, and starts to look like it belongs to you rather than a display room somewhere. Wipeable is not a marketing word here, it’s a small daily relief anyone with children or red wine or both will recognize instantly.
So we’ve landed nowhere tidy, and won’t pretend otherwise, except the ugly one keeps winning arguments it was never trying to have.
