Is a Drop Leaf Kitchen Table Overrated? We Argued About It

There is one person on this team who cannot walk past a folded down leaf without lifting it, just to check, as if the table might have changed its mind since breakfast. Nobody asked them to do this. They do it anyway, four or five times a day, the way some people check their phone. We have started calling it the leaf test and it is not a compliment.

Which is a fair way into whether the thing is overrated, because the honest answer is: sort of, and also not even a little.

Overrated if you think it’s going to behave like a real table full time. It isn’t. Fold both leaves up and you’ve got surface enough for a proper Sunday spread, plates everywhere, someone’s elbow in the gravy.

Drop them and you’re back to a table built for one person’s laptop and one bowl of cereal, sitting there looking faintly embarrassed about it, like it’s been caught out of costume. That gap between its big self and its small self is the whole deal and if you buy one expecting consistency you will be disappointed constantly.

Underrated for the actual apartment living part, though, and this is where half of us go a bit evangelical. One of ours has had hers folded down against the wall for three years in a kitchen you could not swing a spatula in, and it earns its floor space back the second guests turn up, at which point it becomes a table for six and everyone acts surprised, every single time, like they haven’t seen it do this trick before.

You Might Also Like

The Day We Finally Replaced the Taper Candle Holder

What We’d Tell a Friend Buying a Round Rug

Living With a Round Dining Table: The Honest Version

A Leather Footstool Six Months In

The hinges are the bit nobody thinks about until they’re the bit that squeaks at 7am while you’re trying to fold the leaf down quietly so you don’t wake anyone, and fail, loudly, every morning for a week before someone finally oils the thing.

In the evening, though, this is where it wins us all back, no exceptions, not even the skeptics.

Leaf up, lamp on somewhere off to the side, and it stops looking like a piece of furniture doing a compromise and starts looking like something you chose on purpose. Wood grain catching low light, the folded edge throwing a little shadow line down the middle like a seam. It photographs better at 8pm than it does at any hour with the sun actually on it, which nobody expected and which we now openly rely on for house guests who arrive after dark and leave thinking we have our whole life together.

So overrated, technically, if you’re grading it as a full time dining table. Properly good if you understand what you’re actually getting, which is a small table pretending to be humble and a big table waiting for its moment, and one person in this house who will check that hinge on their way past for the rest of their natural life.